To possess Hernandez, the one and only thing shed away from respectable consensual unions is actually legally binding sanction of the condition

Hernandez reasoned you to simple court sanction from a sexual union you certainly will not the only evidence that any particular one was a real and you can moral resident

For some reason my personal suggestion goes from the earliest and you will important institution out-of matrimony, but though we have been and only relationship, as it is suitable of men which build legislation for all of us, we would like to calmly consider man’s РЎasualDates real condition. Taking into account you to definitely laws comes out of facts, these boys enjoys joined here to enter a constitution and that wipes brush the fresh problems of history and you may seeks a new path for the future, [thus] it’s important that they judiciously investigation the new standards of our landscape and reach the end there exists something for the our everyday life plus in our world that we can’t into the any way intimate our eyes, that people need to deal with valiantly. 51

Because of the saying one an effective disjuncture existed ranging from legislators’ beliefs and you can “personal truth,” Hernandez debated one she was assaulting to possess Cubans who had been maybe not aren’t considered to be type intimate propriety and you may, hence, were unjustly disenfranchised

You will find started to the fresh new Assembly so you can moderately protect, on good my personal ability, the brand new Cuban woman, the latest partnered girl, the newest unmarried girl, new light girl, the fresh new black colored lady, women of all the groups. I must declare that there is a large number of Cuban ladies in tough and you may humiliating factors, that as respectable and as worthy of merit as the is most other ladies, that simply since the the woman is when you look at the a free of charge partnership, does not mean that people should think about her and her family unit members depraved. 52

Twenty-a couple out from the 60-half a dozen Construction players attending the fresh training chosen to agree Hernandez’s suggestion. A lot of individuals who voted in favor reasoned so it manage oblige men from inside the consensual unions to get to know a comparable responsibilities and you will requirements one to married people was indeed bound to meet and, thus, perform include all women and kids. Such as for example, modern System representative Capablanca contended one to “though it [Hernandez’s amendment] appears paradoxical, away from are…a strike towards the marriage, it really is a protection from it.” 53 The guy said, “Whenever boys know that they are responsible for people which have which he’s good consensual relationship and also for the youngsters you to definitely effects because of these totally free unions, they doesn’t participate in consensual unions but in wedding.” 54 Capablanca depicted men because nearly naturally reckless, and you may meant that ladies called for County protection from them. Anyone else echoed their rationale.

But not, most System players, progressives and traditionals, balked within Hernandez’s suggestion, arguing that it was not conducive so you’re able to democratic advances and you may manage give rights and you may privileges in order to undeserving, immoral people. Old-fashioned Set up representative Cortina provided a great spirited battle up against Hernandez’s offer, framing his dissent just like the a battle for modernity, progress, and you can civilization. The guy mentioned that an effective constitutional be sure to consider consensual unions equivalent to help you judge marriage ceremonies do fundamentally publish Cuba away from into a legal road divergent off that of “all of the civilized regions on the planet” and you may “destroy…brand new matrimonial system, while making [it] entirely ineffective.” 55 Cortina prophesied, “Whether it amendment was in fact accepted, we might produce a giant confusion in the legal wedded life, therefore create grab the outcomes of governmental revolution and therefore you will find simply resided due to, to groups of our own psychological and you can family unit members existence, [sectors] which don’t need to become turned on the major and you may perturbing method in which is recommended.” 56 To own Cortina, the new 1933 revolution is actually a governmental trend, and you will then change would be to just connect with government: Social products can be left alone.